A great toaster is a staple in any modern kitchen, but it can be tough to choose the right one for you. You want your toaster to not only look sleek in your stylish kitchen, but to toast your bread, bagels, and more to perfection according to your tastes and preferences. Perfect toast is important at every meal, from a sidekick for your eggs, to a perfectly toasted turkey club sandwich. If you’re on the hunt for a new toaster, check out our list of the best ones.
Cuisinart Metal Classic Toaster
Best toaster overall
The Cuisinart Metal Classic Toaster may look retro but it surely belongs to this century with its modern features. This 4-slice toaster boasts multiple toasting functions alongside shade control settings so that you can have your toast just the way you want it. And with extra-wide slots, you can toast all kinds of bread with various levels of thickness. On the off chance, your bread is too small to pop up, its high lift lever allows you to boost the toaster carriage for easy removal without the risk of getting burns.
Why we love it:
- Four toasting slots
- Multiple toasting functions
- High lift lever for easy removal
Hamilton Beach Toaster
Best value toaster
You don’t need to splurge a whole lot of money to get yourself a fine piece of toast and that’s what the Hamilton Beach Toaster is all about. This budget model has two deep and wide slots to accommodate thick slices of bread, bagels, waffles, English muffins, and more. With the high-lift toast boost, you wouldn’t have to worry about your toast not popping up completely. It also has a shade selector that ensures you can brown toast your way and level in its crispiness.
Why we love it:
- Stainless steel material
- High-lift toast boost
- Affordable price point
Smeg 2-Slice
Best retro toaster design
The stylish Smeg 2-slice will complement any kitchen with its retro-inspired exterior. But besides being a toaster you can actually show off, the Smeg also has high-quality features for top toasting performance, including extra-wide slots, a removable crumb tray, and an automatic pop-up function to help keep your bread from burning. Modes include reheating, defrosting, and bagel, with six browning options for toast control. We also really like the little nonslip feet that help prevent it from sliding around.
Why we love it:
- Retro-inspired design
- Crumb tray
- Reheat, defrost, and bagel functions
Dash Clear View Toaster
Best toaster for watching toast
The built-in viewing window on the Dash Clear View allows you to keep a watchful eye on your precious toast. If it just so happens that the toaster has done everything expected of it and you forget about your now-cold toast, the reheat option can be quite useful. The Dash View incorporates seven browning settings, extra-long slots to accommodate breads of an array of widths and lengths, and an automatic shutoff function designed to give some additional peace of mind. The Dash Clear View even comes with access to the company’s expanding list of recipes.
Why we love it:
- Built-in viewing window
- Reheat function
- Seven browning settings
