Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Smart Home
  3. News

Nest User posts video of his frustrating experience with un-silence-able Protect

Add as a preferred source on Google

Whenever we burn something in the kitchen (which happens shamefully often), the smoke detector starts to shriek in protest. Normally, this can be fixed by waving a towel in front of it or, in dire straits, removing the battery while the air clears. But we’ve never had a detector go haywire when there wasn’t a whiff of smoke in the air.

Unfortunately for Brad Fitzpatrick — software engineer at Google and founder of LiveJournal — his Nest Protect decided his house was on fire and sounded the alarm all day. There was neither smoke nor fire, and the frustrated programmer posted a video of himself trying to silence all five of his units to no avail.

Recommended Videos

It’s especially awkward given Fitzpatrick’s employer: Google bought Nest last year for $3.2 billion. Back in April 2014, Nest pulled Protect from shelves due to a software flaw that could potentially cause the detector to “sleep” through an emergency. It went back on sale in June.

Despite working for Google, Fitzpatrick pulled no punches in his Google+ post about his malfunctioning Nest Protects. “They false alarm and are unhushable [sic] pieces of crap,” he wrote. The YouTube video shows him frantically removing all five devices, then playing some nightmarish version of Simon as he pushes the buttons and the Protects continue to say, “Can’t be hushed here.” Finally, he locks them up in a couple of coolers and shoves them in the garage.

Nest Protect does run on batteries, but he was probably a little out of sorts after all the false alarms.

Jenny McGrath
Former Senior Writer, Home
Jenny McGrath is a senior writer at Digital Trends covering the intersection of tech and the arts and the environment. Before…
Pet tech is ridiculous, and I hate how badly I want it
Smart feeders, GPS collars, pet cameras, and health trackers all feel like anxiety with Wi-Fi. The annoying part is that some of them might actually help
Computer Hardware, Electronics, Hardware

One of my cats recently caught some kind of bug, which meant a vet visit, blood tests, and about $135 poorer. After all that, it turned out to be a normal fever. Good news for the cat. Slightly humiliating news for the me who spent the next few hours wondering whether a gadget could've helped me panic more efficiently.

That's the problem with pet tech. It sounds ridiculous until life gives you one weird symptom, one missed meal, or one unusually quiet afternoon. There are feeders that portion meals from an app, collars that track escape artists, cameras that let owners spy on naps, and water fountains that monitor drinking habits because apparently even the bowl needed analytics.

Read more
This Google Home update is all about smarter automation
More control, more conditions, more real-world use.
Google Home Nest Automations Featured

Google isn’t just tweaking Google Home this time; instead, it’s quietly turning it into something far more capable. And the focus is clear: give users real control over how their smart homes behave.

What’s new in the Google Home update?

Read more
Bose turns up the volume on home audio with its sleekest and smartest Lifestyle Collection
Bose's newest home audio lineup arrives with bold promises: cinematic sound without the clutter, a decade-overdue soundbar redesign, and a speaker small enough for your bookshelf.
Bost Lifestyle Ultra ecosystem featured image.

Bose has pulled back the curtain on the Lifestyle Collection. It consists of three new premium audio products, built to work individually or as a unified system: Lifestyle Ultra Speaker ($299), Lifestyle Ultra Subwoofer ($899), and Lifestyle Ultra Soundbar ($1,099).  

All the products promise high-fidelity sound wrapped in materials that are aesthetic enough to double as home decor. Pre-orders for the products are already open at Bose’s official website, and availability begins May 15. 

Read more